The Dickinsonian

  • January 3The Dickinsonian's new website has officially launched! Stay tuned for new stories and features.

Do We Still Need Affrimative Action?

Shea Player ’22, Guest Columnist

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.

Email This Story

Affirmative action as we know it today is a result of the Civil Rights Movement during the 1960’s aiming to provide equal opportunities for individuals in minority groups in education and employment. In light of the college admissions scandal, some critics have attacked affirmative action and claimed that it prevents college admissions from being equitable. In an article in the Stanford Magazine titled “The Case Against Affirmative Action” the authors argue that if affirmative action “were truly meant to remedy disadvantage, they would be given on the basis of disadvantage, not on the basis of race.” What the authors fail to realize is that race, by its very nature, is a disadvantage for those who are not white. 

There are discrepancies among racial categories that impact one’s ability to go to college. According to the Pew Research Center, in 2016 the median income for White families was $47,958 while the median income for Black families was $31,082. In February 2019, researchers at EdBuild, a non-profit organization that examines school-funding issues, found that majority-minority school districts received $23 billion less funding than majority white school districts. The resources available at the high school you attend, and your family income are factors that directly impact your access to college. Schools that don’t receive enough funding or less funding are less likely to offer AP classes and other programs meant to be advantageous for the college application process and it also impacts student performance. There were schools in my hometown that were so in need of renovations that they had no heat and no air conditioning, and this resulted in the cancellation of school simply because they couldn’t regulate temperature.

 As college students, we realize how important money is when making the decision to go to college and where to attend college, and we’ve recently seen how for some, affluence outweighs all other considerations. These factors and many others determine one’s accessibility to college, and as a result of systemic oppression and institutional discrimination the playing field isn’t leveled. For hundreds of years, institutions have limited the access of minorities to education and job opportunities. Why not use the college admissions process to try and level the playing field?

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

2 Responses to “Do We Still Need Affrimative Action?”

  1. Wayne Watkinson on April 11th, 2019 11:58 am

    The essence of discrimination is treating a person differently based exclusively on his or her race or other status. Affirmative action falls within this definition. If we are going to lift up those who have had inferior opportunities which may have led to their failure to meet the performance standards that form the basis for admissions, we should target those most impacted, not those of a particular race. As an extreme example, although the children of Tiger Woods or President Barack Obama would be deemed a minority, I think we can agree that they should not be given preference over a white high school student from an impoverished area.

    I am glad that you have raised this important issue. The courts will continue to examine, and I believe affirmative action in its current form will have a short shelf life and will be replaced by a targeted approach based more on need.

  2. Jamal on April 15th, 2019 11:04 pm

    Yeah, we done need dat cuzz me not be gettin none job, y’all.

The Dickinsonian strives to provide a forum for lively and respectful discussion among members of the Dickinson College community. We reserve the right to remove any comments that we do not adhere to our community standards.

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.


The student news site of Dickinson College.
Do We Still Need Affrimative Action?